Which Ingredient to Use?

Which Ingredient to Use?

Dr. Radhika Ganesan explains, “For high acid beverages with a pH below 4.6, we typically recommend whey proteins due to their superior solubility and heat stability at lower pH levels. Conversely, for low acid beverages, which generally have a pH between 6 and 7, milk proteins are preferable. Milk proteins provide optimal solubility and heat stability in this pH range.” The choice of protein source significantly influences the formulation, processing, and the challenges encountered during production and storage.

Examples of Protein Sources:

  • Whey Proteins: This category includes whey protein hydrolysate (WPH), whey protein concentrates (WPC), whey protein isolates (WPI), and milk-derived whey.
  • Milk Proteins: This group comprises milk protein concentrates (MPC), milk protein isolates (MPI), and micellar casein concentrate (MCC).

In formulations with higher pH, milk protein concentrates (MPCs) are typically used as the primary protein source, whereas whey protein concentrates (WPCs) are favored in low-pH beverage formulations. This strategic selection ensures that the beverages are not only effective in meeting nutritional requirements but also stable and palatable throughout their shelf life.

Milk Protein Concentrate (MPC) and Milk Casein Concentrate (MCC) are highly valued for their rapid digestive and absorptive properties, making them ideal for neutral pH protein-fortified beverages. MCC, a relatively newer dairy protein, contains a higher ratio of casein compared to MPC. Both ingredients are excellent sources of essential amino acids and provide slowly digestible protein that promotes satiety.

In contrast, whey proteins are more heat-sensitive during prolonged exposure to high temperatures, which can lead to denaturation, aggregation, and gel formation. However, whey proteins are favored for their excellent solubility and ability to remain dissolved across a broad pH spectrum. This makes them particularly useful for fortifying acidic beverages, typically with a pH range of 2.8 to 3.5.

The following table compares the characteristics of protein isolates and concentrates

Factor Protein Concentrate Protein Isolate
Cost Lower Higher
Lactose Content Higher, Contributes to overall sugar Content Lower, less sugar Content
Mineral Content Higher, Can Affect Stability based on PH Lower
Fat Content Contains Some fat, resulting in a Cloudy, Milky Product Minimal to no fat, resulting in Better clarity
Product Clarity Less Clear, more Milky appearance High Calrity, Ideal for Protein waters
Overall Preference Chosen for Cost-efficiency Preferred for Lower Sugar Content Clarity

Key contact

For further information or prices please contact us: